Peter has a secret, something so hidden that the Eternal Youth has repressed all memory of it. When Captain Hook and his men discover that the Boy-Who-Never-Grew-Up is actually a girl, Peter's world begins to crumble around her. The fairies turn their backs on her, her friends are taken away, and the only beings in Neverland she can turn to are her sworn enemies. The horrors worsen as Peter's long forgotten memories are awakened, and the hapless girl begins to realize just why she decided to play her biggest pretend all those years ago.